| |
| Gold Mining Stocks: Blood, Sweat and Tears |
| |
By Kenneth J. Gerbino
Aug 11, 2006 |
 |
|
|
Metal markets have been in a strong bull market
for four years. Currently a correction and sideways consolidation
is in progress. Normally, pullbacks and consolidations are part
of all long term up-trends in any market. Not withstanding all
the bullish fundamentals in a world floating on printed money
and debt there are always corrections and sharp pullbacks in the
gold sector. This goes with the territory.
With the Fed still terrorizing all markets with
their interest rate policies, actions and statements (all totally
anti-free market) expect plenty of volatility for a long time.
The Fed cannot stop inflation with rate hikes. This is a huge
misconception by the Harvard-Yale-London School of Economics-NY
Times-WSJ-Stanford-Goldman-Sachs-MorganStanley-WashingtonPost-Georgetown-dinner
party axis. Please see The
Fed Can’t Stop Inflation article posted on our website.
Unfortunately some money managers and hedge fund managers with
huge multi-billion dollar portfolios who are new to the mining
sector and certainly the gold market can create havoc if they
line up on one side or the other of the inflation-gold-interest
rate equation. This will create opportunities and plenty of danger
in the years to come.
Gold’s $200 advance during April and May might
have implied the possibility that an unraveling of one of the
many very extraordinary economic time bombs that are part of the
investment landscape could be suddenly evolving. One can never
be sure if a derivative meltdown is about to start or a global
housing bubble causing defaults by the hundreds of billions (on
risky adjustable and the new gimmick mortgages) or some major
banking or insurance group in trouble could create some sort of
monetary panic. The fact that global stock markets were also pounded
in May and June makes one a believer in the value of gold assets
despite the moves up and down. Gold has since recovered and is
now around $640.
This recent volatility was unfortunately just a
warm up to what is most likely in store for precious metal investors.
If you were uneasy with this correction, are you prepared for
gold going to $1,000 and then back down to $600 sometime in the
future and then perhaps back up to $1,500. One needs to be able
hedge with in the money puts, go short overvalued stocks or have
a policy of taking some off the table on substantial run ups.
Xerox back in its heyday went from $1 to $170 and then back to
$45. A decade later it was at $4,000 (split adjusted). You would
have had a hard time riding it down from $170 to $45 but you would
have missed the great move up if you had bailed out. So an investing
policy and basic strategy is vital to do well in the mining sector.
I always tell people keep at least 50%
invested always in case gold explodes one morning but don’t
be afraid to take some profits on run ups and find new and better
values to invest in with that cash….and buy on the pullbacks.
Money and Power
Lining Up at The Gold and Base Metal Window
This pullback in the precious metals has allowed
the more conventional global money managers, who so far have not
embraced the metals, to start looking at gold related assets.
Swiss giant UBS is the largest gold bullion trader in the world.
In a recent report they noted that up to 20% of commodity portfolios
tracked by their trading desk are being allocated to precious
metals. AIG, one of the largest financial institutions in the
world announced that their Japan unit alone may invest $4.4 billion
(3% of assets) into commodity related assets to diversify away
from stocks and bonds. Governments are also being heard from;
Russian President Putin announced that the Russian central bank
will raise their gold holdings from 5% to 10%. With $237 billion
in reserves (expected to rise another $100 billion this year from
oil sales) this allocation alone
would require about half the global mine output this year. Yu
Yongding, Chinese monetary committee member recently called for
China to diversify a portion of their $875 billion reserves into
gold. World powers live by, but also are beginning to lose confidence
in, paper money.
China is now the 2nd largest consumer
of oil in the world versus only 10 years ago when it was 20th.
Oil consumption is a solid measure of economic activity and this
stat is telling the world that base metals and precious metals
will be in high demand next - as hundreds of millions of new middle
class consumers buy jewelry, air conditioners, televisions and
cars. Massive infrastructure projects will also require large
quantities of base metals – and a U.S. or Chinese recession
will not stop bridges and roads and power lines being built in
China. Huge state projects (in any country) are financed by paper
money or government debt and are recession proof.
Volatility and Value
So far, this spring and summer has been volatile
for stock markets globally. Hong Kong was down 10%, Germany down
9% and Singapore down 18% in May and June. The Indian stock market
lost 10% in one single day. Commodities,
precious metals and mining stocks had large sell offs and swings.
The US stock market had four days with over 200 point swings in
the Dow (compared to only five such days the previous five months).
The major cause of this global volatility was that the Bank of
Japan had lent out hundreds of billions of dollars to domestic
banks and this money was lent to large international hedge funds
over a two year period. The Bank of Japan then abruptly
called in these loans. Don Coxe, the extraordinary and brilliant
strategist at the Bank of Montreal, called this “unprecedented
in the history of modern central banking.” A global liquidation
took place as these funds were forced to sell everything in sight
to raise cash. The few hundred billion was significantly leveraged
so somewhere between $750 billion and $1.5 trillion of global
financial assets had to be liquidated in a very short time period….gold
and gold shares were part of this liquidation.
It appears that many good mining companies have
temporarily sold off more than fundamentals dictate. All markets
experience sell offs that sometimes push asset values to very
undervalued levels. This is what happened to the precious metal
stocks, this conclusion is bolstered by the fact that over the
last five years there have only been four instances where the
Net Asset Values of the major and intermediate mining stocks have
been trading at such a low valuation to their discounted cash
flows. All four of these instances saw
a significant rally occur from those levels. Also the senior
precious metal mining sector is currently trading at only 9 times
2007 expected cash flow – historically very undervalued
territory. In relatively mild to good metal markets these stocks
usually trade between 15-25 times cash flow.
Own Good Merchandise
One owns mining stocks for various reasons: portfolio
insurance, long term capital preservation, some alternative money
versus printed paper, inflation hedge, and financial diversification.
One also has to make sure the mining stocks owned have the minerals
in the ground and have a good shot at economically recovering
those minerals. The price we sometimes have to pay for these attributes,
as well as above average performance, is above average volatility.
We are both a value investor and a production growth
investor. We want the stuff in the ground and we want to see a
2-3 year growth profile for a company. In my opinion, the sweet
spot in the mining industry are companies that are expanding and
building mines that will produce gold on average for under $250
per ounce, allowing for significant cash flow, profits and upward
share price valuations. The long term prospects are also excellent
for base metal companies with multi-billion dollar deposits of
valuable metals that a new global economy will demand in greater
and greater quantities in the years to come.
Your portfolio should be diversified in various
metals but concentrated in the precious metals. We are expecting
strong capital gains in this sector. The best companies are the
ones with quality mining projects coming on stream and are well
funded and have substantial investment banks behind them to fund
these and future projects. The worst companies are the risky exploration
stocks. For those who want some leverage and would like
to trade warrants (long term options) you could check out www.preciousmetalswarrants.com.
They cover the Canadian and U.S. companies. Warrants are more
risky, so be careful if you allocate some portion of your risk
capital and go that route, and stick with established companies
or those with plenty of resources.
In the long term the political-economic landscape
for almost all governments is a policy of printing money and increasing
debt levels to meet the overwhelming medical and retirement demands
of their electorates. Gold assets are historically the most reliable
and therefore the preferred asset class when a period of fiscal
and monetary problems are coming on stream. This will surely happen
in the future. Gold assets insure some wealth protection in an
uncertain future plagued by paper money and debt.
The graph below shows if gold stocks are over or
under valued versus the underlying price of gold. The higher the
ratio the more undervalued gold stocks are. At current ratios
one should own the shares.

The summer is usually a slow time for the developmental
mining companies. Most of the Canadian and European financial
people are on extended vacations and taking constant three-four
day weekends. The mining people are all out in the field drilling
and expanding deposits. The summer work programs are usually extensive
and the results are usually published at the end of August through
November. This is usually a strong period for mining companies
and it also coincides with strong gold bullion demand from wedding
seasons in Asia and buying by jewelry fabricators for the holiday
season.
The long term prospects for gold and mining stocks
appear to be very strong and should prove to be the best asset
class in the coming years to invest in. For more articles on gold
and mining stocks visit our website at www.kengerbino.com.
Kenneth J. Gerbino
*****
Kenneth J. Gerbino Kenneth J.
Gerbino & Company 9595 Wilshire Boulevard, Suite 303 Beverly
Hills, CA 90212 Telephone: (310) 550-6304 Facsimile: (310) 550-0814
E-mail: kjgco@att.net
|