|
Web Note
The following short story is hypothetical in nature,
but is based on what was, what is, and what will be.
Meet John and Terry Wheeler,
January 2003
For
John and Terry Wheeler it was a dream come true. The
opportunity had finally arrived. It was a chance to
move out of their small apartment and finally own a
home of their own. They had always dreamed of owning
a home, but there was never enough money. Terrys
tips from waitressing at an upscale steakhouse had enabled
the couple to build a small kitty of $5,000, but that
didnt cut it. Homes were expensive in southern
California and it seemed no matter how much John and
Terry brought home, housing prices moved further out
of reach. That is until Terrys aunt passed away
leaving her a small inheritance. The $20,000 bequest
wasnt much, but with the drop in interest rates
their realtor said that with the right financing package,
they would be able to swing the deal.
In March of 2003 their dream became a reality. They
purchased a small home in the suburbs for $515,000.
The yard was small and the homes were close together,
but they didnt seem to care. After living in a
1,000 square foot apartment since they got married,
Terry thought their new home was a palace. Thanks to
the realtors advice of taking out a variable rate
mortgage, they were able to get a 3% starter loan, which
brought the payments on their $490,000 mortgage down
to $2,100 a month. With property taxes and insurance,
their combined incomes were able to handle the $2,500
a month outgo. Besides, Johns job as an electrician
paid well and with all of the new homes being built,
John was getting time and half for working overtime.
Business began to pick up at the local steakhouse and
on weekends Terry took home more than $500 in tips.
By working three lunches a week in addition to her five
nights, Terrys income was beginning to catch up
with Johns.
These were good times. With Johns overtime and
the extra money Terry made working lunches, the Wheelers
had enough money to buy Terry a new car. They were able
to buy a brand new Ford Explorer for less than $400
a month thanks to zero percent financing. Times were
so good that they even had enough money at the end of
the month to put a little extra aside into savings.
Terry wanted to buy furniture for the living and dining
rooms with their extra earnings and the tax refund they
received from the Presidents tax cuts. John had
his eye on a new 52 inch LCD TV for the family room.
With their cash savings they were able to pay cash for
the LCD TV. But the furniture was too expensive. Terry
didnt want to wait. The furniture store offered
them an attractive financing package that made the purchase
tempting. John was hesitant, but he found it hard to
say no. After all he had gotten the new TV. How could
he say no to Terrys desire to furnish an empty
living and dining room? The furniture payments wouldnt
start for another two years. When they kicked in, it
would add another $360 to the monthly budget. By then
they hoped they would have enough cash in the till to
pay down the loan and reduce their payments.
If
the overtime kept up and business at the restaurant
remained strong, they would still be able to handle
the additional payments when they were due. However,
the overtime and weekend tips were now a necessity.
Without them there would be very little left over in
the budget at the end of the month. But that was a worry
for another day. Right now times were good and 2003
ended up as a memorable year. A new home, a new car,
new furniture, a new LCD TV what else could a
couple ask for? This was living the American dream.
John felt good enough about his new job. With a major
new development going in, the overtime pay would continue.
That Christmas he bought Terry a set of diamond earrings
on credit. Terry wanted to make this Christmas special
for John. She had her eye on the home entertainment
system that would be the perfect compliment to the new
TV. The system cost more than $2,500, so she charged
it. Terry figured that her tips would enable her to
pay off the credit card within a year. That year's Christmas
was one they would never forget. The $4,000 in new credit
card debt would be a monthly reminder.
The Wheelers Feel the "Pinch"
in 2004
2003 ended well and the couple was hopeful that 2004
would bring more of the same. Johns overtime continued
and Terry still made $500 or more in tips on weekends.
But in March they got a bit of a shock. Last October
their mortgage payment went up by $100 a month after
the bank raised their mortgage interest rate from 3%
to 3.5%. They had expected an increase, but were a bit
troubled after the mortgage company raised the rate
another half a point. Their adjustable rate mortgage
adjusted every six months, but they were assured by
their realtor at the time of purchase that interest
rates would remain low. They were now paying 4%, which
was still less than a fixed rate mortgage, but the rate
hikes had increased their monthly payments by more than
$240 a month. Terry was also beginning to complain about
the cost of groceries and the price of gasoline. It
now cost more than $56 a week to fill the tank of her
new Ford Explorer and the weekly grocery bill had risen
by more than $20. Their property tax bill went up in
April and they also were paying more on monthly utilities.
These were all small things, but they were starting
to add up. John and Terry still managed to put aside
$150 a month, but it wasnt as much as they hoped
for.
The monthly credit card payments were now over $120
a month and over the last year they found themselves
buying more things on credit. They bought a portable
barbeque and new patio furniture in the spring. Terry
really wanted a spa for the backyard. The backyard was
too small for a swimming pool, but the pool company
could build a nice spa and waterfall in the corner of
the yard for $15,000. Their credit card balance was
now over $8,000, so charging it was out of the question.
John called their realtor who suggested a home equity
loan. Houses in their neighborhood had been appreciating
by more than 2% a month. The realtor told John their
home had appreciated by more than $100,000 over the
last 15 months. John took the realtors advice.
Their home's appreciation made John and Terry feel richer.
They now had more than $125,000 in equity, which was
hard for them to believe. Terry wanted to put in the
spa by summer. Besides the new spa, Terry also had her
eye on a new bedroom set. The furniture store had been
running sales every weekend. A new bedroom set would
cost more than $12,000 and John wanted another TV to
fit in the armoire. John called the mortgage company,
figuring they would need about $35,000 to pay for the
spa, bedroom set, new plasma TV and pay off their credit
cards. John found it absolutely amazing how easy it
was to get credit now that they had become homeowners.
Getting credit had never been this easy. Buying their
new home had been the best financial decision they ever
made.
During that summer John and Terry took their first
vacation since their honeymoon. Carnival Cruise line
was offering a package tour of the Mexican Riviera for
only $2,500. It was bit expensive, but with their credit
card debt paid off and their home continuing to appreciate,
John felt they could afford to charge it. They came
back from their vacation refreshed. Terry was pleased
with some of the purchases they had made in Mexico.
There were new pots for the back yard, nic nacs for
the family room and beautiful silver jewelry for Terry.
The purchases had set them back another $1,000, which
they also put on their credit cards.
It all seemed affordable especially now since their
home kept appreciating. Their combined mortgages was
$525,000. That was more than the original purchase of
their home. But the way John figured things, they were
still ahead. A call to his realtor had reassured John
that things were okay financially. Their home was now
worth more than $625,000. Even though their debt balances
were larger, they were still ahead by almost $100,000!
They were living the good life. Johns overtime
continued and Terry still made good money at the steakhouse.
The couple were thrilled with their new home. Terry
loved all of her new furnishings and John was considering
adding a covered patio off their family room. It would
provide the shade they needed to cool the house down
from the summer heat. A call to their mortgage company
provided the needed cash. John got the $7,000 he needed
to put in the new patio cover and Terry wanted to replace
the family room Venetian blinds with wooden shutters.
John asked his mortgage broker for a $22,000 loan. That
would give him enough money to build the new patio cover,
put in the family room shutters and pay off their credit
cards.
At summer's end, their credit card balance was back
over $5,000. There was always something that came up
each month and there never seemed to be the extra cash
around to pay for things. It became easier to charge
things. John and Terry had not realized it, but charging
things each month had now become a way of life. Terry
complained about their grocery bills. Costs seemed to
be going up everywhere and their grocery bill had gone
up by more than 40% over the last three years. Her last
office visit to her gynecologist cost her $80. A trip
to the dentist to get her teeth cleaned cost $58. Prices
were going up everywhere and it was beginning to pinch
their budget. In October of 2004 the mortgage company
raised their mortgage rate by another half a point to
4.5%. John complained to his mortgage company, but the
broker told him that his variable rate mortgage was
still cheaper than a fixed rate loan.
John was getting worried. Their mortgage payment was
now over $2,500 a month. Property taxes on their new
home were going up along with their mortgage payment.
Taxes and insurance now added up to $600 a month. In
addition to their regular mortgage, they now had a $47,000
home equity loan. This cost them an additional $200
a month. Add in the $75 minimum payment for their credit
cards and it all was starting to take its toll. Making
matters worse was the fact that their home equity payment
went up almost every month. Not by much, but enough
to irritate John. The bank told him it was because the
Fed was raising interest rates. The home equity loan
was tied to the prime rate. When the prime rate went
up, so did Johns monthly payment. John didnt
understand economics, but he began to understand that
every time he saw Alan Greenspan on TV, it meant his
mortgage payments were going up.
Although John and Terry were still happy, they found
themselves arguing more over money. The end of each
month left them in a tight spot. They stopped going
out to movies every Sunday. Out of necessity they both
decided it was best to stay away from the shopping malls.
Terry tried to save money on groceries by using coupons
and buying more household cleaning supplies at Wal-Mart.
These were small changes, but they helped to balance
their budget. Johns union had negotiated a pay
raise and his boss still needed John to put in the overtime.
They were thankful for their new home and good fortune,
but by year-end they both agreed to pull in their horns
at Christmas. They managed to get through the Christmas
season by adding only $1,500 a new credit card debt.
There wasnt enough in checking at the end of the
month to pay for discretionary luxuries. The difference
was made up with credit cards. The cutbacks that John
and Terry had initiated made the budget balance each
month, but there was very little left for unexpected
expenses a trip to the dentist, new tires for
Johns truck or simple repairs around the house
or birthday, anniversary or Christmas presents.
When John and Terry added up assets and liabilities
at the end of 2004 they were still on the plus side.
One of their neighbors had sold their home for $650,000.
It was the same model as John and Terrys. Their
realtor told them that their home might be worth a little
more with the patio and spa addition. Although their
mortgage and credit card balances had increased in 2004,
they were able to upgrade their home with new shutters,
a spa and patio. Terry was happy with the way the house
looked, so John anticipated no new expenditures for
2005. If the house continued to appreciate like it had
the last two years, it would more than make up for the
difference in mounting credit card bills. They looked
forward to the new year with all of their major expenditures
now behind them. The new home construction market was
still strong in San Diego. Johns only worry was
Alan Greenspans frequent appearance on the evening
news. That meant higher interest rates and John worried
what would happen in March when it was time for another
mortgage adjustment.
J. Gordon Grecko Fortune's
Friend
What John and Terry could not know as they began 2005
is that approaching financial and political storms would
soon impact them in a personal way. Events in Washington,
a crisis on Wall Street and an escalation of the war
in the Middle East would push them to the brink of insolvency.
John knew that when Mr. Greenspan spoke, bad things
happened to his monthly budget. He and Terry were about
to find out about another man J. Gordon Grecko
who would have an even deeper impact on their
mortgage payments. Terry knew of Gordon Grecko from
watching entertainment programs. Terry knew he was fabulously
rich and had had many glamorous wives and well publicized
divorces. Heir to a publishing fortune, Grecko had made
his own fortune on Wall Street by running one of its
most successful hedge funds. John and Terry knew little
about what Grecko did for a living other than he was
very rich and had a beautiful wife.
The only reason Terry knew his name was because Grecko
was a publicity hound. Grecko found that his patrician
background and the publicity helped to open doors
especially when it came to obtaining credit from investment
banks. Grecko was a bright star on Wall Street and everyone
wanted to rub shoulders or be in business with Grecko.
Grecko made money as easily as the Fed expanded credit.
Grecko could have been another trust fund brat, but
he had inherited his fathers brains and ambition.
He had gone to Yale and then on to Harvard for graduate
school. Grecko found he had a gift with numbers and
finance. After graduation there was only one outlet
for his ambition and that was Wall Street.
The senior Grecko had sold the family publishing business,
which freed him to pursue another ambition in politics.
When the senior senator from New York retired, Grecko
senior stepped into his shoes. It had been an expensive
election, but easily handled by a family fortune that
numbered in the billions. Greckos political connections
were helpful in opening doors, but Grecko juniors
talent and smarts were what landed him a job on Salomons
bond desk. By the time Grecko arrived on Wall Street,
the staid and predictable bond world was pulsating with
change and opportunity. There he found a man who would
change his life forever. John Meriwether was a rising
star at Solomon and Grecko was only too happy to become
one of Meriwethers protégés. Under
Meriwethers tutelage, Grecko learned the intricacies
of bond arbitrage. Bonds trade on mathematical spreads.
The riskier the bond, the wider the spread hence
the greater the difference between a bonds yield
and a similar yield on risk free Treasuries. These rules
are the bible of bond trading. They are responsible
for creating a matrix of different yields and spreads
on debt securities around the globe.
What Grecko learned at Solomon and from Meriwether
is that bond spreads would occasionally widen in a time
of crisis. But if you had the staying power to ride
out the storm, spreads eventually narrowed and reverted
to the mean. The key was staying power and that meant
having plenty of access to credit. Access to credit
was what allowed you to stay in the game. Credit was
also what enabled you to turn nickels into dimes, dimes
into quarters, and quarters into dollar bills.
Grecko had always been comfortable with numbers, but
he learned to not trust them completely. The difference
between him and the other quants on the bond desk is
he had developed a knack for reading the economic tea
leaves better than anyone else. It was what made Grecko's
calls stand out and stand far above all of his peers.
Grecko was developing his own style of trading. He preferred
to make large macro bets. Once he understood the big
picture, he relied on his models to refine his position.
The success he was having at Solomon was also giving
him the confidence to go out on his own. Eventually
the bond dream team at Solomon split up. Meriwether
set up his own shop at Long Term Capital Management.
With his mentor gone, it was time to set sail on a new
course and begin a journey that would make him both
famous and infamous at its end.
Wall Street was changing rapidly during the 1990s.
The Fed was creating vast sums of credit and much of
it was making its way to Wall Street. Large sums of
money were pouring into mutual funds. The public was
coming into the market in a very big way. The catalyst
had been lower interest rates, which made the returns
on fixed income investments seem less attractive. Deregulation
was in the air, making it easy to get into competitive
businesses. Banks were becoming brokerage firms and
brokerage firms were becoming banks. With governments
borrowing vast sums of money, the debt markets exploded
exponentially.
Grecko Makes It Big
There was also a technology and communication revolution
taking place and it was revolutionizing the street.
Better information, faster data feeds, and instantaneous
communication moved markets at lighting speeds. There
was talk of a new era and Grecko was capitalizing on
it. His family name and reputation put Grecko on a first
name basis with many of Silicon Valleys CEOs.
He was connected with all of the movers and shakers
in the markets, whether it New York, Washington, or
California. While his mentor at Solomon focused his
fund on debt markets, Grecko was consumed by technology.
To Grecko technology was the big picture. His hedge
fund stayed focused and concentrated its holdings in
the technology sector. Being well connected provided
him with access to the numerous technology and Internet
IPOs. His fund was making a fortune. His own net worth
and reputation grew as he added additional zeros to
his net worth.
Grecko was glad he stayed focused on technology. Too
much money and credit were making the bond market unstable.
Signs of stress were visible in Asia. Grecko unwound
his bond positions at the beginning of the year and
concentrated his positions mainly in technology with
smaller bets in healthcare and financials. He was glad
he did. The Asian tsunami finally hit the credit markets
in the summer of 1997. Grecko was relieved he was out.
The next year he noticed that credit spreads continued
to widen and remained mostly out of the debt markets.
That single decision saved his fund. Instead of debt,
he had loaded up on Internets taking a sizable position
in Amazon.com and AOL.
By 1999 Greckos own fortune made the Forbes 400
list making him one of Americas wealthiest individuals.
But the market was getting too frothy for his own comfort.
Some of his technology holdings would double in a month
only to double again the following quarter. He began
to see that the party was soon coming to an end. That
summer the Fed had embarked on a series of interest
rate hikes. Grecko knew that would eventually mean pain
for the markets and the economy. That summer he began
to quietly unload the fund's technology holdings and
moved into cash and short-term bonds. It was a good
call. The fund ended the year up with a 70 percent return,
keeping pace with the NASDAQ and making his clients
as well as himself happy and wealthier.
Grecko Makes His Millennium Mark
Grecko turned even more cautious in 2000. He stayed
out of the markets even though the NASDAQ kept climbing
to even greater heights. Instead he began to gradually
build up his bond positions, figuring by summer the
Fed would be through raising interest rates. Once again
his instincts had proven to be correct. Stock prices
were falling; the economy was slowing down, and a presidential
election cycle was starting to heat up. Markets hate
uncertainty, which is why Grecko remained out of the
markets. He continued to build the fund's cash and bond
positions. Grecko stayed focused on treasuries throughout
all of 2000 and 2001 a position he held until
the end of 2001. After the attacks on 9/11, the Fed
injected massive amounts of money into the credit markets.
Greenspan was slashing interest rates with a furry never
seen before. The money supply was growing at double
digits. Never before had the Fed created so much money
and credit out of thin air.
Money
and credit began to flow everywhere. Interest rates
fell to half century lows. For Grecko, that meant it
was time to change strategies. It was an easy time to
obtain credit. For his hedge fund that meant it was
time to leverage up and look for bigger arbitrage opportunities.
J. Gordon Grecko returned to what he had learned at
the Solomon bond desk. The fund began to leverage up
its portfolio. Greckos name, reputation and his
fathers position in the Senate had the investment
banks lined up at his door handing out cash. His reputation
for accurate market calls had the investment banks believing
Grecko printed his own money through higher returns.
By the end of 2002 his fund was leveraged 20-1. By the
end of 2003, leverage had increased to 30:1. The fund
continued to move into higher risk positions. With interest
rates falling and hedge funds multiplying like rabbits,
arbitrage opportunities were getting harder to find.
This made it necessary to take the fund's leverage position
even higher and move even further towards the tail end
of the curve. By the end of 2004, leverage in the fund
was approaching 40:1. That year profits in the fund
were $6.4 billion. To put that in perspective, that
return was more than what Caterpillar made selling earth
moving tractors and trucks. It was more than Sears made
selling washers, dryers and tools. It was enough money
to put Greckos fund on par with another cash flow
machine: the energy sector. The funds profits put Grecko
in the same league as big oil.
The fund made that money as a result of two decisions;
a correct call that credit spreads would continue to
narrow rather than widen and long-term interest rates
would head down rather than up. Those two correct decisions,
combined with leveraging up the balance sheet, made
the fund a fortune that year. The brief hiccup in interest
rates in April and May made the firm's creditors a bit
nervous. Grecko reassured them. As interest rates came
back down again, investment banks opened up their checkbooks
and virtually gave the fund a blank check. By the end
of 2004 the fund's balance sheet carried over $150 billion
in debt debt that was tied to every major investment
and money center bank on the Street.
While
a few of the fund's traders were beginning to get nervous
with the leverage that the fund was taking on, they
had absolute confidence in their boss. The amount of
leverage was sizable, but it paled by comparison to
the leverage and the derivative books of the major money
center banks. The growth in credit derivatives was explosive.
In the last fifteen years, the derivative book at major
money center banks had grown from a paltry $10 trillion
to $90 trillion by the close of 2004. Interest rate
contracts made up the bulk of those contracts (87%).
Five commercial banks held 95% of the notional amount
of derivatives in the commercial banking system. Most
of these contracts were illiquid. Over 92 percent were
OTC (over-the-counter) related. Only 8% were plain vanilla
type contracts that traded on the major exchanges. Piedmont
Bank was the largest player on the street. They insured
and backed almost everybody. BankUSA was second and
CitiStreet came in third. These three players
accounted for 90 percent of all derivatives in the banking
system. They lent to and insured everybody.
Grecko knew all the major players at each of the banks.
He played golf and tennis with most of them. Each one
of the banks had a major stake in Greckos fund
either directly through credit or as counterparty to
the fund's derivative plays. It was a close and chummy
group. In many ways, it was incestuous. Everybody had
a stake in each other's business either through credit
lines or hedges. The close relationship between all
of the players is what created the risk.
Grecko ended 2004 with a complete assessment of his
risk aggregation, breaking down his fund's exposure
according to counterparty. Theoretically, things were
supposed to be hedged with everyone protected. That
was theory not reality. Derivatives allowed you
to hedge a risk, but not eliminate it completely. In
essence risk was never eliminated. It was simply transferred
to someone else. The hope was that that transfer of
risk ended up in stronger hands. Counterparties to a
derivative transaction were protected by their collateral.
The collateral held up only as long as no one big failed.
In the case of a failure of a major player, each one
of its counterparties would attempt to sell out their
positions. The problem arises when everyone sells at
the same time. When everyone sells, the value of collateral
backing each transaction evaporates. In the case of
failure of one counterparty, the effect would be to
leave the other counterparty naked; holding only one
side of a contract when the other side no longer existed.
When this takes place, each counterparty rushes for
the exit gate at the same time. This is equivalent to
a bank run. Markets can lock up and in extreme cases
cease to trade at all.
The possibility of a lock up was the least of Greckos
worries as he planned his strategy for 2005. He continued
to believe that long-term rates would continue to fall
and bet that that the 10-year note would fall to 3.86%
by spring. By February his confidence was growing that
his call was correct. The 10-year note had fallen to
below 4% by the second week of February. He was also
betting that risk spreads would continue to narrow.
He intended to use even greater leverage to counter
lower spreads. It was what he had learned from Meriwether.
It was the leverage that turned the nickels and dimes
into quarters. However, spreads were thinning and borrowing
costs were going up with each Fed rate hike. The fund
started to move further out on the risk scale shorting
swap spreads. Swap rates were a fixed rate that banks,
insurers, and major investors demand in exchange for
paying the LIBOR rate, a short-term bank rate. The problem
with LIBOR rates is that they are variable and it's
difficult to determine where they will go in the future.
By using derivatives Grecko had taken the fund's leverage
to the extreme. With arb opportunities thinning out,
the solution was more debt. The combination of debt
and derivatives is what enabled the fund to turn its
dimes and quarters into dollar bills. By early spring
the firms derivative book had grown fourfold.
Leverage had grown to the highest level in the firms
history. Greckos firm, WedgeBook Partners, had
$20 billion in equity, $150 billion in debt and controlled
assets of $1.5 trillion.
Grecko's WedgeBook Partners Turned
Fractions Into A Whole Lot of Money
While WedgeBook had become one of the major players
on the street, their risk exposure was small in comparison
to its creditors. With the average investor out of the
markets buying real estate, the financial markets had
become the exclusive domain of the big boys the
money center banks, hedge funds and investment banks.
John Q had abandoned his mutual funds in favor of real
estate investing. The retail end of business had become
so slow that investment banks were laying off their
staff of technical and research analysts. Nobody was
interested in long-term investing anymore. The money
was made by trading. Using leverage allowed you to get
more bang out of each trade. It was what multiplied
fractions and turned them into whole numbers. The markets
had become the exclusive playground of the rich and
powerful and Grecko was one of its big players.
By the end of March the fund was going
further a field. WedgeBook had become a major player
in the Russian debt markets. However, even there spreads
had narrowed considerably. By late spring Russian sovereign
debt yielded no more than 200 basis points over Treasuries.

In addition to narrowing credit spreads, short-term
borrowing costs were continuing to rise. The Fed had
raised the federal funds rate at its March FOMC meeting.
The notes accompanying the meeting indicated that further
rate hikes were on their way. This presented a problem
for the fund. The yield curve was beginning to flatten.
Borrowing costs were going up, while the returns offered
on fixed income securities continued to fall. This impaired
profits. The firm's computers were failing to find opportunities.
Grecko needed an edge and a call from Piedmont provided
the answer. With short-term borrowing costs rising and
long-term fixed returns falling, the fund needed a cheap
source of capital. Piedmont suggested selling gold bullion.
Gold lease rates had fallen dramatically with one year
rates no more than 20 basis points. Gold had continued
to trade within a narrow $20 trading range for the last
three months. The dollar was rallying, which would keep
gold in check. As the stock market struggled with each
new Fed rate hike, money was pouring into the Treasury
market. This lowered interest rates and raised the value
of the dollar. The Piedmont suggestion of selling bullion
made sense. WedgeBook sold 100 tons of gold short at
$420, thereby netting the fund an additional $1.3 billion.
Gold continued to trade in a very short range throughout
most of the spring and the fund continued with its gold
short sales. By summer WedgeBook had sold short by 500
tons and net more than $7 billion, which was redeployed
into higher returning investments. By summer the firms
portfolio was looking more exotic. It showed just how
difficult the markets had become with nickels and dimes
harder to come by. Almost half of the portfolio was
made up of junk bonds and emerging debt. Nearly one-third
consisted of interest rate swaps with the balance of
the fund in everything from energy shorts, equity pairs,
and foreign currencies, to long and shorts on various
indexes. The most profitable trades had been the precious
metal shorts. In addition to the gold short sales, the
fund had also begun to accumulate a sizable short in
silver. WedgeBook had sold over 20,000 contracts short
silver when silver had been above $8. The precious metal
shorts were accounting for most of the firms profits
this year. By late spring and early summer the fund
was printing money again. Its clients were pleased with
their mid-year report, which was already showing double-digit
returns.
The Perfect Financial Storm Brews
and Breaks
Returns on the fund reached their peak in early July.
From that point forward it was all down hill. By the
end of August, the financial and political world began
to take on a life of their own. A series of events were
about to unfold that would shake the markets to their
very core. The collapse of WedgeBook and the near bankruptcy
of its creditors would be one of those events. The other
storm was in the Middle East and an unexpected event
here at home. But for now those events were far away.
As summer set in, Grecko was in the mood to relax. He
decided to spend a few weeks in Europe in July. August
would be spent at his beachfront mansion in the Hamptons
before his return to a robust schedule in the fall.
Before embarking on his trip to Europe, Grecko reviewed
all of the firms positions and felt comfortable
with most of them. Credit spreads had started to widen
again, but the firm's profits were large enough to provide
a comfortable cushion. Gold and silver lease rates were
flat and as along as they stayed that way, with the
metals trading in a narrow range, Grecko had no worries.
Besides, the markets were usually dull during the summer,
so he anticipated no major surprises. The trouble spots
that would surface by the end of the summer were barely
visible on the radar. Isnt it always this way?
A bomb is dropped, a president or archduke is assassinated
or jet planes fly into a building, and suddenly a tinderbox
is lit, a crisis erupts and the world suddenly appears
different. At the moment, volatility continued to fall
and as long as it kept falling ,the financial world
remained stable.
The problem no one paid attention to is that debt levels
had risen to unimaginable levels. The culprit was low
interest rates. Double-digit bond yields were a thing
of the past. With hedge funds multiplying like viruses,
the only way to earn a respectable return was through
the use of leverage. Hedge funds were resorting to borrowing
to inflate their returns. It wasnt just the hedge
funds. The money center banks had leveraged their balance
sheets in ways that were beyond description. The money
center and investment banks were the real problem. They
were the ones extending the credit. They were the insurers
of last resort. In the world of derivatives where risk
was passed around like a hot potato, they were the ones
holding the bulk of the potatoes.
The investment markets had learned from the crises
of the 90s and this new decade that if things
got bad enough, the markets could always rely on the
Fed. In essence it was the Fed who stood behind the
banks. If troubles emerged, they could always rely on
the Mr. Greenspan. The Fed chief could be counted on
when it mattered most when liquidity evaporated
and markets locked up. Greenspan would keep cutting
interest rates until liquidity to the system was eventually
restored. In following this familiar pattern, a moral
hazard had been created that permeated most of Wall
Street. Its major players knew that they could continue
to move further and further out on the risk curve knowing
they always had the Fed as a safety net to catch them
if they fell. Greenspan had opposed any form of regulation.
Instead, he praised the innovation and productivity
of the financial markets. His opposition led to a lack
of disclosure when it came to measuring risk. While
most investors might be able to distinguish basic balance
sheet risk, they were ill prepared and uninformed when
it came to off balance sheet debt and completely befuddled
when it came to derivative risk. If debt isnt
clearly shown or has been removed from most financial
statements, most investors dont know where to
find it. In the case of derivative exposure, there was
a gaping hole left from deregulation that had yet to
be plugged. This hole widened each year with the derivative
book of money center banks expanding exponentially.
The other unrecognized problem was measuring risk itself.
On Wall Street risk had been defined as volatility.
It permeated most trading rooms on the Street eventually
becoming the Holy Grail of finance. It was as if closing
prices each day meant something other than what they
were. A closing price told you nothing about company's
on and off balance sheet risk. Prices couldnt
forecast a firms derivative risk nor disclose
the risk of its counterparties. All most traders knew
or cared about was what the models told them. That fact
that some future trade or price would deviate from the
norm was considered a statistical freak. Rogue waves
were viewed as infrequent events and something that
their models had statistically eliminated. The problem
with most of these models was that they were based on
pure mathematics that imbued an air of certainty when
in reality none exists. That was where the hubris lies.
Just because you havent seen one recently doesnt
mean one wont appear. There would come that one
day where they would appear out of nowhere, without
warning, undetected, taking the markets by surprise.
That is when dangers of leverage come home to roost.
If you have no debt, you can hold on to your positions.
You cant be forced to sell and you won't go broke.
Leverage gives way to the same brutal dynamic. It cuts
both ways. It magnifies gains on the way up as well
as multiplies losses on the way down. Yet for many on
the Street including Grecko, they had become immune
to risk as a result of the moral hazard. What Grecko
had learned in his time spent on the Solomon bond desk
was that you ride your losses until they turn into gains.
If you had access to capital to stay the course, you
would be rewarded in the long run. Grecko had that access,
which is why the amount of leverage in his fund gave
him little cause for worry. That confidence would be
shaken before the summers end. Events were about
to unfold in many unexpected ways in unexpected corners
of the markets and in the economy. It wasnt just
Greckos world that would be shaken to its core,
it was also the world of John and Terry Wheeler.
To be continued...
Jim Puplava
****
The material on this website has no regard
to the specific investment objectives, financial situation,
or particular needs of any visitor. It is published
solely for informational purposes and is not to be construed
as a solicitation or an offer to buy or sell any securities
or related financial instruments. References made to
third parties are based on information obtained from
sources believed to be reliable but are not guaranteed
as being accurate. Visitors should not regard it as
a substitute for the exercise of their own judgment.
Any opinions expressed in this site are subject to change
without notice and Financial Sense is not under any
obligation to update or keep current the information
contained herein. PFS Group and its respective officers
and associates or clients may have an interest in the
securities or derivatives of any entities referred to
in this material. In addition, PFS Group may make purchases
and/or sales as principal or agent. PFS Group accepts
no liability whatsoever for any loss or damage of any
kind arising out of the use of all or any part of this
material. Our comments are an expression of opinion.
While we believe our statements to be true, they always
depend on the reliability of our own credible sources.
We recommend that you consult with a licensed, qualified
investment advisor before making any investment decisions.
|