Make Kitco Your Homepage

Gold & Silver Are More Relevant Than Bitcoin - DeCarley Trading

Kitco News

Editor's Note: Carley Garner, president of DeCarley Trading, provided exclusive commentary for Kitco News' 2018 Outlook Series.

(Kitco News) - Gold and silver have taken a backseat to Bitcoin-mania, but they are still more relevant assets.

Carley Garner, president of DeCarley Trading

Bitcoin has dominated the financial news cycle, but in the long run, this particularcryptocurrency might be more bark than bite.  Although the technology of blockchain and cryptocurrencies will live on, the way the financial markets have pinpointed Bitcoin as the end-all-be-all for the complex is arguably flawed logic. The cryptocurrency idea is less than a decade old and will undoubtedly experience growing pains. Many believe Bitcoin is the start of a new era capable of changing society in a manner similar to the internet. How soon we have forgotten the struggles of technology pioneers. Remember

Considering the mania, it is hard to believe Bitcoin was created as an experimental currency and involves the practice of solving math equations to “mine” the asset. Since when does doing algebra instantly create a valuable asset? Further, Bitcoin was never intended to be an investment vehicle and would likely prove to be less valuable than just about any tangible asset on the planet should the world undergo a calamity. In short, its astronomical value is the result of perception not reality.  This isn’t a new concept in the financial markets, but we’ve never seen emotions get this out of hand.

Some argue these characteristics are no different than those of gold; that is a reasonably true statement.  I’ve always had reservations regarding the practicality of gold being an efficient medium of exchange, but the truth is it has been used by mankind for millennia. More importantly, the gold market is extremely deep.  Investors in gold bullion, casual collectors, technology manufacturers, and those valuing its beauty, are all holding a piece of the pie.  The Bitcoin market, on the other hand, is believed to be largely owned by roughly 1,000 market participants with uninformed retail traders scrambling to bid up the price of scraps.

Despite the excitement over Bitcoin and the widespread expectations that it is a sufficient replacement for gold, there are some serious consequences of holding Bitcoin relative to gold that the market is not currently accounting for.  These security risks might be enough to counterbalance the yearning for massive gains which might never be realized due to challenges in logistics in liquidating cryptocurrency assets in an illiquid environment and a lack of regulatory safeguards. To be clear, we are not fans of big regulation in the financial industry but we’ve been around long enough to know that some common sense regulation is necessary. In our opinion, the lack of governmental control over the brokerages offering cryptocurrencies flings the door wide open to opportunity for fraud.

For instance, one of the appealing aspects of Bitcoin is the fact that it bypasses banks and other financial intermediaries. This introduces a counterparty risk that most other financial transactions and assets aren’t exposed to.  There have been a handful of Bitcoin brokers leave the business due to solvency or fraud issues. Those holding Bitcoin at those particular brokerages are simply out of luck. In short, customers who wired funds to such brokers to “invest” (I use that term loosely in this instance) in Bitcoin in hopes of a get rich quick outcome, discovered their funds were used by the brokerage in other way and was gone. Even if their funds did go toward Bitcoin purchases, the assets were liquidated to satisfy priority debt holders of the firm leaving investors with either nothing to show for their efforts or initial principle or in a best-case scenario nickels and dimes on their dollar. Keep in mind, these counterparty risks apply only to those attempting to buy actual Bitcoin via the various brokerages offering the asset, it does not apply to Bitcoin futures contracts.  The counterparty risks of Bitcoin do not apply to Bitcoin futures in which all transactions are guaranteed by the exchanges listing them (Chicago Mercantile Exchange and Chicago Board of Options Exchange). Nevertheless, Bitcoin futures are (at least in theory) tied to the underlying Bitcoin price itself, so although the exchange guarantees the futures market transaction itself, there is obviously no guarantee the trade will make money. In other words, the exchange ensures that speculators on both sides of the trade live up to their end of the bargain.

Also, the internet is riddled with stories of Bitcoin holders who have lost access to their Bitcoin assets due to hacked computers, compromised email accounts, or simply losing an associated pin number. Gold and silver bullion investments, on the other hand, are generally sitting in a bank safe with protections most citizens wouldn’t be capable of employing on their own.  If the bank is robbed, there is likely some recourse to recoup the value whereas a Bitcoin holder digitally “robbed” of the asset will never be made whole.  Accordingly, the new security risks associated with “investing” in cryptocurrency are far greater than most are willing to admit. As flawed as gold is, it has a long history of survival and relevance.  That is more than we can say for Bitcoin.

Now that we’ve established that precious meals are a more legitimate asset than the existing cryptocurrencies, let’s peek into what might be in store for both gold and silver as we head into 2018. That said, we hesitate to make any bold calls in such a lengthy time horizon. A year is a long time and the fundamental backdrop can change dramatically.  Recall late 2015, the stock market and most commodities were in the dumps but by early 2016 the markets were stable and in some cases roaring higher. In other words, it is important that we avoid getting sucked up into the current narrative and keep our eyes open for shifts in sentiment.

Throughout the latter part of 2017, both gold and silver waffled in price due to a lack of interest. This isn’t surprising, traders are focused on alternative assets such as Bitcoin, the stock market is performing better than nearly all periods in history, and there hasn’t been an immediate need for risk off assets in recent years.  Accordingly, precious metals have fallen victim to a lack of attention and trading interest.  Nevertheless, sometimes the best opportunities are in those markets the masses aren’t paying attention to. Eventually, the focus will change and investors will look toward the traditional safe-haven assets for a place to diversify.  On a side note, I am the first to admit that gold and silver are generally volatile markets with little resemblance of safety but the fact remains that the value of precious metals tends to rise along with uncertainty. Given the stock market’s ability to have avoided a significant correction for over two full years, it seems likely 2018 will bring some sort of equity market pullback leaving investors yearning for alternative assets.

Gold Futures Chart

Gold futures appear to be poised to hold the $1,230 to $1,200 support levels as determined by uptrend lines. We’ve seen multiple gold slumps in recent years but they have all eventually been met with buying; we suspect this time will be no different.  If we are correct about that, gold should retest resistance at $1,350 and if fundamental news supports it, a move toward $1,420 is in the cards.  While we are not anticipating a run to $1,485, a significant unforeseen news event could trigger such a rally.

It is remarkable how well the Slow Stochastics indicator has worked in the gold market.  Of the last ten occasions dating back to 2012, nine buy signals triggered by the oscillator has resulted in a subsequent upswing.  That said, the single failure taking place in early 2013 was an utter disaster for anybody aggressively long the gold market so caution must always be warranted. The Slow Stochastics indicator is currently displaying a buy signal (the oscillator is in oversold territory with a reading of 20 or below and the oscillator is beginning to point upward). If the trend of successful Slow Stochastic signals continues as expected, we should see gold recover from late 2017 weakness.

Silver Futures Chart

The silver market has been similarly “forgotten” by speculators.  Thus, it too might be poised for a comeback. Whether it is a fizzle in Bitcoin prices or the stock market, the precious metals market would likely be a direct beneficiary.  Although few have noticed, the silver futures market has shifted from a trend of lower lows to one of higher lows.  We’ve yet to see higher highs become a norm but there are definitely budding signs of a bull market on the horizon.  Assuming the support range between $15.50 and $15.00 continues to hold, the bulls could press silver prices well into the $17.00s.  Should a break of trendline resistance occur near $17.25 we could get a quick run into the low $20.00s. We are not expecting an immediate return to the $25.00 level, such a move cannot be ruled out should fundamentals make a sharp turn.


The metals markets have historically proven to be subject to boom and bust cycles with the best booms occurring after lengthy bust cycles.  The emergence of Bitcoin probably isn’t a game changer in the precious metals arena (yet). Years of directionless trade on a lack of inflation worries combined with the market’s response to Fed tightening might have resulted in pent-up demand for precious metals. If so, 2018 could be a breakout year.  If not, at least traders should continue to feel comfortable getting bullish on sharp pullbacks leading to oversold conditions on a weekly chart as determined by the Slow Stochastics in combination with standard technical support analysis.

Disclaimer: The views expressed in this article are those of the author and may not reflect those of Kitco Metals Inc. The author has made every effort to ensure accuracy of information provided; however, neither Kitco Metals Inc. nor the author can guarantee such accuracy. This article is strictly for informational purposes only. It is not a solicitation to make any exchange in commodities, securities or other financial instruments. Kitco Metals Inc. and the author of this article do not accept culpability for losses and/ or damages arising from the use of this publication.

Precious Metal Charts

Follow Kitco News

1 oz Gold Bars